Blog · SpecSmith

StrategyQuant X and MT5 results differ: check the broker profile

A common reason an exported strategy behaves differently in MetaTrader 5 has nothing to do with the strategy. StrategyQuant X keeps its own description of each instrument, and if it differs from what your broker’s terminal reports, the two programs charge different amounts for the same trade.

  • Published 2026-11-12

What differs

Tick size, tick step, point value, minimum stop distance, order size step, decimals, swap, commission and trading session are all stored per instrument in a broker profile. A profile copied from another broker, or set up years ago, can disagree with today’s terminal on any of them. Spread is a special case: the MT5 export holds one moment’s spread, which is not a representative cost, so SpecSmith leaves it off unless you ask.

Seeing the differences

Run the AWSpecExport script on a chart in the terminal logged in to the broker you trade. It is read-only and writes two CSV files to Common\Files\AWSpecs. In the SpecSmith tab of the Data Manager, choose the export and a broker profile and press Compare with MetaTrader. Each row shows Differs, Matches or Not in SQX, and a double-click shows the old and new value of every field, with its unit. Nothing is written by comparing.

Units

Some conversions are worth knowing before you read a row. Tick size is the tick step, times ten only for three- and five-digit forex, which is how SQX defines a pip. Point value is the MT5 tick value divided by the tick size, so the label reads dollars per 1.0 move, per lot. Swap stays in raw MT5 points. Commission comes from the terminal’s commission rules, and SQX charges it once, at the open of a trade; if your broker charges per side and you want the round-turn cost, there is an advanced round-turn option.

Applying and undoing

Tick the rows to change and press Apply ticked rows. The dialog states how many changes it will write and into which profile. The values they replace are saved to a backup first, and Undo an apply restores them and removes anything the apply created. Projects you created earlier keep their own copy until you redeploy them.

What it cannot do

SpecSmith does not guess your broker’s clock. MetaTrader gives only today’s UTC offset, which says nothing about daylight-saving history, so the timezone is yours to set. The point value of a symbol quoted in another currency moves with the exchange rate, and SpecSmith reports it only when it is more than 10% off. Interest-based stock swaps have no SQX equivalent and are left alone. Exact commissions need MetaTrader 5 build 6060 or later.

Risk

Trading leveraged instruments carries a high risk of loss. Software output is not investment advice and says nothing about future results. Validate every strategy yourself before risking capital.